
Hucklesby and I are out for our twilight walk up the mountain. Will I see Moonlight this time?
Today isn’t a good day for me. It’s Valentine’s Day, a day which brings, unbidden, images of what my life might have been, if only I’d made better decisions as a younger woman.
Regret, however, is a bitter companion. I prefer cats.
Like Hucklesby. A gray cat the color of twilight on a misty day. Though I might have been accompanied by other cats on my road not taken, none of them would have been my Hucklesby. He lives with me in my cabin in the woods but comes along on my twilight walks and never runs astray.
Up the trail, Hucklesby and I reach the little waterfall that I call Heart’s Chalice. It must be the most beautiful place on earth. It’s not well-known like the Blue Hole, down the creek a ways. The Blue Hole is a sweet spot – in pretty weather, lovers meet there to park, neck, and skinny-dip.
But it was at Heart’s Chalice where, on Valentine’s Day forty years ago, Robert proposed to me, and I’d split our paths in two, never to meet again. Why? Because Mom hadn’t liked him, thought his head was too far in the clouds to be "a good provider." At age twenty, I’d let her wrest my truest love from me and throw it away like a rock into the creek. The ripples still pummel me to this day.
On two of my last five twilight walks, I saw Moonlight. And on those nights, I dreamed of Robert and me: dreams so vivid – each more vivid than the last – that on the first blush of consciousness before dawn, I thought I was somewhere (somewhen) else: with Robert, young again, my life to live over, ripe with possibility.
The full light of day shone, instead, on the path I actually walk. But it isn’t bad. Not anymore. I have my Hucklesby.
And Heart’s Chalice.
I start, delighted and… expectant. There’s Moonlight, sniffing as he picks his way along the rocks on the opposite side of the bank near Heart’s Chalice. The fluffiest cat I’ve ever seen, he must feel like silk. I wouldn’t know – I’ve never touched him.
Moonlight looks well-cared for and wears a blue collar with a silver tag. He’s colored like moonlight transformed into fur, and his face, tail, ears, and paws are kissed with dark silver. Raising his head, his whiskers twitching, he watches me with sapphire eyes. Then he sniffs the rocks, moving nearer to where the water falls, froths, then flows. What’s he after?
Hucklesby plays in the fallen leaves on the trail. Odd that he pays no attention to Moonlight; usually, he hisses at other cats. Hucklesby has been an only cat for ten years, since my divorce. Harry wouldn’t tolerate cats in the house, so the first thing I did after removing our marriage from life support was go to the animal shelter and pick out Hucklesby.
Moonlight’s sniff quest takes him through the twisty laurel thickets to the giant tree above Heart’s Chalice where Robert carved our initials over forty years ago. Though the carving is faint, I can still see it: MLN + RMA, enclosed by a heart. Misty Laurel Nave plus Robert Michael Arrowood. Forever.
The tree’s still here, I’m still here, but Robert isn’t. Ten years ago, he died of drink and disappointment, far away from here.
Something has changed on the tree: an arrow now pierces the heart. Robert? My breath catches with anticipation, but I free it reluctantly. I’m not in my dream. Though this trail isn’t well-used, people hike here, and some of them probably like to carve on trees.
Years ago, I’d wanted to carve an arrow, but Robert stopped me. He thought the arrow would be tacky, given his last name. We’d both been poets, aware of words. I wonder if, deep in his heart, he’d seen what was headed his way: not the sweet sting of Cupid’s arrow but the anguish of mine.
Moonlight paws at the tree, gazing at the heart, the initials, the arrow. I study them more closely. They look fresher, like somebody spruced them up with his pocket knife.
No, not “his” anything. Only my imagination. A breeze carries away my sigh.
Moonlight disappears behind the giant tree. I watch, wait for him, but he doesn’t reappear. Where did he go?
I haven’t crossed the creek branch in a few years, but there are plenty of rocks, my legs are sturdy, and my balance is good. I have to see if Moonlight is curled up behind the tree, tucked in a hollow, or…
Or what? Where else would he be?
Holding my arms out for balance, I step, with a sneaker-clad foot, on the first rock. Pity I didn’t wear my waterproof boots, but I hadn’t planned on crossing the branch. Okay, here I go – don’t think too hard, just walk. Wobbling only a little, I make it to the opposite side of the bank, then I scramble up and round the tree.
There’s no hollow in the tree; Moonlight is gone. But he’s been here, all right. On a moss-covered rock gleams a silver tag identical to the one on his collar. The evening isn’t cold, but I shiver: the tag reads “Moonlight.” Underneath is an address I don’t recognize and “Robert and Laurel Arrowood.”
Laurel. I never could stand Misty. Harry had called me Misty.
The tree is no longer gigantic. It’s merely big, like it was forty years ago. And the carving on its trunk looks sharper. It could have been done yesterday.
Or today.
I hear a plaintive meow.
Across the creek branch, Hucklesby sits on his haunches. Come back to me, he seems to say, peering at me as if he can’t see me well. Perhaps, to him, I’m disappearing.
Could Moonlight live somewhere that Robert still lives and breathes; is Moonlight our cat? Is that how I know his name? Has Moonlight been looking for me, trying to bring me home, where I belong?
But I can’t leave Hucklesby. If I’m going to chase a phantom into a dream, I’ll take my boy with me.
My tremors have calmed, so I put the silver tag in my jeans pocket, cross back over the creek branch and pick up Hucklesby, cuddle him close. I look back; the tree is again gigantic, Robert’s long-ago carving looks faint. The arrow is gone.
Night has fallen – time to go home, time to dream. Perhaps time to travel. The full moon hangs in the sky, ripe with possibility.


